Review Form: 1st International Workshop on Services and Infrastructure for 
the Ubiquitous and Mobile Internet (SIUMI'05)
Columbus, Ohio, USA, June 6th, 2005

In conjunction with the 25th Int. Conference on  Distributed Computing Systems (ICDCS’05)


Reviews should be emailed to the Technical Program Co-Chair
Antonio Corradi acorradi@deis.unibo.it by January 30, 2005.
________________________________________________________________________________________


Paper Number:
Paper Title:
Authors:

Reviewer:



Please rate the submitted paper according to the following parameters:


Familiarity
Rate your familiarity with the topic
1 Novice
2 Some knowledge
3 Familiar
4 Expert


Significance
Technical relevance and practicality of ideas in the paper
1 Not significant
2 Somewhat significant
3 Highly significant


Novelty 
How original the problem and/or solution method is
1 Not novel
2 Somewhat novel
3 Highly novel


Quality of Presentation
Writing and presentation style/accuracy
1 Poorly written
2 Could be improved
3 Well written


Overall Recommendation
1 Strong reject
2 Weak reject
3 Weak accept
4 Accept
5 Strong accept		


Please provide comments about the following points:

Contributions
(what are the major issues addressed in the paper? Do you consider them important? Comment on the 
degree of novelty, creativity, and technical depth of the submission)







Strengths and weaknesses
(in brief, what are the major reasons to accept/reject the submission?)







Detailed public comments
(provide detailed comments that will be helpful to the TPC for assessing the paper, as well as 
useful feedback to the authors)